Sunday, March 3, 2013

The Strange Case of Arun Joshi


This essay was published in the March 2013 Hindu Literary Review

Is the greatest Indian English novelist all but out of print? This much is certain: Arun Joshi deserves better. The author of five novels, written mainly during the 1970s, who won the Sahitya Akademi award for his penultimate book, The Last Labyrinth, barely registers as a name today. At least two of his books are out of print, none are easily available. Yet his themes are the most vitally contemporary of all our early English novelists, his characters vividly like us- English-speaking, urban, wracked with confusion- and the quality of his art and thought are both first-rate and arguably far superior to (say) Rushdie (to whom Indian English writing is said to owe a great debt). But if all this is so, what explains his obscurity?

Part of the answer may be, the man's personality. According to some accounts, Joshi was reclusive and publicity-shy. He certainly didn't climb the publishing ladder like his contemporaries did. Along with most other writers of the time who wrote in English but lived in India (Joshi headed the Shri Ram Centre for Industrial Relations in Delhi), he published locally- with Orient Paperbacks. But even through the 1980s and beyond, post-Rushdie, when Anita Desai, Khushwant Singh and others had moved to foreign or multinational brands, and Penguin India had set up shop, and publishing was starting to become the big-ticket affair it is today, Joshi was still with Orient. (He remained there till his death in 1993, nor, to date, has anybody else published his novels.) It is not the case that his merits were unknown in his lifetime. He had won the Sahitya Akademi award in 1981. Did he not push his wares hard enough?

This could be; we don't know. But we know a general truth, which I suggest applies squarely to the case of Arun Joshi: that it is the man with his finger on the pulse who risks being dashed aside, not the glib talker at the safe distance. That a writer can be ignored, precisely for being too relevant. In exploring seriously and unapologetically the psyche of his very own 'set'- the privileged and the upwardly mobile, who read, wrote, talked and thought in English- Joshi was breaking ground that has never afterwards been mined- that has in fact been guiltily filled up again, in the years since he published. As a result, his themes, that leap from the page from sheer relevance, lie buried today in a kind of ashamed but aggressive silence.

Consider his best-known book, The Strange Case of Billy Biswas, published in 1971. It is the story of the son of a Supreme Court judge, educated in New York, who leaves his comfortable Delhi life, his marriage and his friends, to become a tribal healer in the Maikala Hills of Chhattisgarh. It is a 'sensational' plot; Joshi was habitually guilty of slight excesses in that regard. It is also exciting, wise, beautifully constructed, and one of the best English novels written anywhere in the world. Billy's conversations with the narrator, his old college friend, now a conventional but thoughtful bureaucrat, delineate Joshi's concerns. 'What got me', Billy confides, years after his transformation, 'was the superficiality...I don't think all city societies are as shallow as ours. I am, of course, talking mainly of the so-called upper classes.. I don't think I have ever met a more pompous, a more mixed-up lot of people.' 'Well', answers the narrator, 'you know why they are mixed up, don't you? Centuries of foreign rule, the period of transition, economic insecurity and so on'. 'I can understand that', says Billy, 'but for God's sake they have at least got to think about it. If they don't, the period of transition, as you call it, is going to last forever and ever.'

This excerpt may suggest, at first, a certain cynicism- the familiar breast-beating of our present-day literary elite- but Joshi is simply too good for that. The shallowness of middle class society is not for him a point of rhetoric, intended to show off his own enlightened superiority, but a theme to be explored with actual concern. He never mocks the men and women whom he critiques. That is why they come to life. Here is Leela Sabnis, from The Last Labyrinth: 'M.A. and PhD. from Michigan, something else from London, short, shapely, small-breasted, skinny, trained in philosophy, emancipator of women, married and divorced, believer in free love, harbinger of a new order of things, reformer of the body and a mechanic of the spirit, a good lover...Leela Sabnis was a muddled creature. As muddled as me. Muddled by her ancestry, by marriage, by divorce, by too many books.' This extract condenses the character, but I hope conveys something of the sheer reality of Joshi's material. Leela Sabnis is a woman one recognizes.

So is her 'muddle.' And Joshi explores the muddle of our English-speaking elite, up and down through his first four novels. He knows that it is the wellspring of a great deal of violence, of 'the blind blundering vengeance' that stalks Billy Biswas, and the sham and hypocrisy that creep over The Apprentice. That, Joshi's third and perhaps greatest novel, is a searing account of a young governmant servant's descent into careerism and corruption. Published almost four decades ago, no novel could be more acutely relevant to our times. There are lines like prophecy. 'We are defeated and we celebrate victory! God exists and does not mind graft! We sink and think we are swimming. Strange... We are a very strange nation.' But perhaps no bookshop stocks it.

This is both tragic and not surprising at all. When the general consensus among our critics is that privileged Indian English novelists cannot possibly have any great themes of their own to grapple with, that all the meaty material lies in 'other' Indias or in other languages, that non-fiction may as well take over from fiction- when such idiocies (the right word) abound- then the last thing one knows how to place is the absolute seriousness and unabashed introspection of an Arun Joshi. When I mention that it is the spiritual starvation of the elite, their unattended need for faith and God, that is his ultimate theme, you will see the gap between his thought and the prevailing thought. Nevertheless, it is worth considering, that even as we celebrate writers from the world over, we may have forgotten the best of our own.

30 comments:

  1. More the coverage lesser is the delivery hassle. That’s the core characteristic for the online gift delivery. For meeting the client’s satisfaction level, this timing is very much essential, and ExpressGiftsIndia.com is really the one to count on this. Having location coverage spanned over numerous locations, clearly it’s the concern that meets your urgency for delivering the bought gifts at right time. A large and distributed network reduces the transportation time, and this time reduction contributes the timing of delivery. Visit www.expressgiftsindia.com/delivery_locations.aspn for more details.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Keep your loved ones happy by delivering this delicious Cake with the classic arrangement of flowers that will sure be loved and admired by your friends. Our online site www.cakedeliveryinnoida.com
    is full of many varieties of Cakes which will ready to deliver top your location. Just join with me and Send Cakes to Noida

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wonderful blog & good post.Its really helpful for me, awaiting for more new post. Keep Blogging!





    Fruits Gifts to Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  4. Deliver gifts and flowers to several cities and states of USA along with tasty treats and beautiful floral decorations. Send Gifts and Flowers to USA with the lovely collections of flowers that is available at www.giftflowersusa.com that is meant for connecting you with several locations of USA.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Send Rakhi special wishes to your dear brother with a wide collections of Rakhi found in our website. Just let your finger click at www.rakhiworldwide.com/rakhigifts/send_rakhi_to_Pune.asp and Send Rakhi to Pune and other Indian cities.

    ReplyDelete
  6. If you are looking for a way to send flowers to any ware in india then availing the service of the online flower delivery portals.
    Visit:send flowers to kolkata

    ReplyDelete
  7. Your gifts are always the X-factor to the celebration of your loved ones in Pune. It brings a new color to the life canvas, and sings foreternityofyourrelations.Visitwww.puneonlineflorists.com/city_delivery_locations.asp for more information.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I truly appreciate this post. I’ve been looking everywhere for this!
    online florist in delhi

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nature’s special beauty is being gathered at one place to impress your dear ones with its beauty in first chance. Again you can send your wishes in a mind blowing way. Send Flowers to Delh ith the contents of www.delhionlineflorists.com that allows you to deliver your gifts to various locations of Delhi.

    ReplyDelete
  10. It was really information about arun joshi case post. Thank you so much for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am really impressed by see your article It Is So Interesting post What a fabulous challenge,Really it will help lot of people . I am very happy to read your article I am very much looking forward to upcoming challenges, I mean to say . . who doesn't like to your this blog thanks for sharing with us.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you this information is very useful thanks for sharing. Buy Devotional Idols and Picture Frames

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great post!! I love your content and Thank you very much, I have found this info extremely good! Mumbai Online Florist

    ReplyDelete
  14. am so impress to read your this blog such a great job dude and who dose not like your this blog i meant to say all are like your this blog because your this blog is so so useful am so happy to read your this blog god bless u and thanks to sharing us.Send Gifts To Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  15. i like your blog it is so interesting am so happy to see your blog thanks to sharing me
    Same Day Flowers Delivery In India

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thank you for sharing this is really good article

    i Like Send Flowers To Delhi
    this is great post

    ReplyDelete
  17. : Online Cake Delivery in Pune, Cake Delivery in Pune, Cake shops in Pune, Midnight Cake Delivery in Pune, Order Cake Online Pune, Online Cake Order in Pune, Best Cake Shop in Pune,Send Cake to India, Cakes to India ,Send Cakes to India

    Online Cake Delivery in Pune

    Send Flowers to Pune, Flower Delivery in Pune, Flower Delivery Pune, Online Flower Delivery in Pune, Flowers Delivery in Pune, Flowers to Pune, Pune Flower Delivery, Online Flowers Delivery in Pune, Send Flowers to India, Flowers to India


    Send Flowers to Pune

    ReplyDelete
  18. That's a nice information you have shared. Thanks for sharing this. I appreciate it very much.

    Send Flowers To Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  19. I'm really glad that I found your wonderful post. I enjoy reading it and I learn a lot.
    Send Flowers To Goa

    ReplyDelete
  20. Brothers and sisters, this festival, sister’s glad, it is possible to find every gift basket! Stout, former gift baskets, and more blessed to give than it is. Often, breads, cakes, cookies, authorization and greetings, photo gallery, gourmet chocolates, scented candles, gift baskets, plush pillows and rich in flavor. Send Rakhi to UK Sweet, many strange, and a permanent collection of letters, took the best selection of gifts for Rakhi maturity. If you see my sister, I have many emotions in the face, I will be surprised!
    That is how beautiful gift besides chocolate bouquets of flowers. They are very good, very beautiful and more attractive. Decorate with chocolate all sectors and regions more powerful than the color of the flag wrapped in candy wrappers. Chocolate, brown, chocolate, dark chocolate, milk chocolate, chocolate candy, nuts, almonds, raisins and nuts and chocolate bouquet, sweet chocolate contain receivers. Furthermore, the heart-shaped chocolates, and professional cycle, such as the various models of wood, can be circular.
    http://www.rakhiwithlove.com/send-rakhi-to-uk.html

    ReplyDelete
  21. Rakhi, we will start to prepare in advance. The colorful market stall will display all the scenes of Rakhi festival. Rakhi girls to start early in order to purchase this Brother, you do, Rakhi, his brother, avoiding the need to buy new clothes to buy, especially for people. Sweet shop, clothing store, a gift shop, all to attract buyers immersed in a wide range of products. People marvel, after the festival when Rakhi is a tendency to buy.

    In terms of family traveler, the bonds of love and care for all the brothers, now we have the right to visit family and relatives live in the home. Send Rakhi to uk Right wrist "to connect the negative, is the life" and relatives "strengthen the protection of. And.

    Brother and sister, traditional festival
    Brother "brother worship", "", Defense and brother visited him in his conviction the application amount, saffron rice. In the design of a variety of writing a Rakhi Clear, cotton, beads, pearls, colorful cotton simple silver jewelry, complex models can be of various sizes and equipment..

    Traditionally, the festival of exchanging gifts back brother fortunate and lucky most important characteristics of gifts. Raksha Bandhan, the colors in a delicate and lasting love relationship may be important to protect, you can pull a lot of money and gifts.
    www.rakhiwithlove.com/send-rakhi-to-australia.html
    www.rakhiwithlove.com/send-rakhi-to-USA.html
    www.rakhiwithlove.com/send-rakhi-to-canada.html
    www.rakhiwithlove.com/send-rakhi-to-UK.html

    ReplyDelete
  22. A lot of people usually are content to pick online method for transmitting gifts because of the excellent good quality associated with providers they get. Send Flowers to Mumbai So, when you would like to express ones wishes to be able to anyone while you usually are living away from these people, people precisely recognize what direction to go.
    www.eflowerstoindia.net/flowers-to-mumbai.html

    ReplyDelete
  23. I was reading through examining studying some of your blog posts on this site and I believe this site is very instructive! Retain posting.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Rakhi, we will begin to plan ahead of time. The beautiful business sector slow down will show every one of the scenes of Rakhi celebration. Rakhi young ladies can begin buy right on time. So She can buy Online Rakhi to Pune to her Brother. You do, Rakhi, his sibling, keeping away from the need to purchase new garments to purchase, particularly for individuals. Sweet shop, apparel store, a blessing shop, all to draw in purchasers inundated in an extensive variety of items. Individuals wonder, after the celebration when Rakhi is an inclination to purchase.

    Send Rakhi to Patna @ http://www.rakhiacrossworld.com/send-rakhi-to-patna.html
    Online Rakhi Delivery to Aligarh @ http://www.rakhiacrossworld.com/send-rakhi-to-aligarh.html
    Rakhi to Bhopal @ http://www.rakhiacrossworld.com/send-rakhi-to-bhopal.html

    ReplyDelete
  25. welcome of new year 2016 with new Josh Unlimited DJ DHOL whisky rum party
    new year packages near delhi

    ReplyDelete
  26. hi nice blog it was too goodhttp://www.nortoncontactnumber.co/

    ReplyDelete
  27. NiceNice blog, I like your blog you also see this topic blog, I like your blog you also see this topic

    ReplyDelete
  28. I am so impressed to see your blogspot I have learned many things from your blog it is truly helpful thanks to sharing us.

    ReplyDelete